mirror of
https://github.com/obra/superpowers.git
synced 2026-06-12 05:39:05 +08:00
a8406dc678
Adversarial review findings (A1-A7, D3):
- BLOCKER A1: the re-gating tripwires lived only in the HARD-GATE, but
the skip decision happens at the description (our own GREEN-attempt-1
evidence). The description now carries the tripwires: adds a
file/dependency, touches schema/API/persisted data, deletes or
disables anything, alters behavior/security posture, >1 plausible
reading.
- A2: "a schema/API/data question" was defeated by "the user answered
the question"; now touch-based ("even if the user stated the desired
outcome").
- A3: destructive changes and behavior/security-visible changes had no
tripwire (pure removals were structurally invisible); both added.
"a literal config value change" example now qualified ("with no
security or behavioral consequences").
- A4: the checkbox example no longer teaches hedge-phrase = fully
specified ("where the context leaves nothing to choose").
- A5: "EVERY project regardless of perceived simplicity" now ends
"with exactly one exception below" instead of contradicting it.
- A6: rationalization table added (codebase-pattern, infer-the-obvious,
hedge-phrase, asking-wastes-time).
- A7: anti-pattern opener is a claim again ("Anything with open
decisions goes through this process").
- D3: exception states TDD and verification-before-completion still
apply, so the fast path does not read as zero-oversight.
Description: 689 chars (limit 1024), YAML-validated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>