Compare commits

..

1 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Drew Ritter
ded04a41e3 fix(codex): suppress SessionStart hook auto-discovery with empty hooks object
Codex auto-discovers a plugin's hooks/hooks.json whenever the Codex
manifest has no `hooks` field: load_plugin_hooks falls back to a
hardcoded DEFAULT_HOOKS_CONFIG_FILE = "hooks/hooks.json" and registers
it. hooks/hooks.json is the Claude Code SessionStart hook, it is tracked
in this repo, and the Codex marketplace installs the whole repo root
(source url "./"), so the fallback re-registered the SessionStart hook
and its install-time trust prompt on Codex.

Removing the Codex hook file and the manifest `hooks` pointer (commit
"Remove Codex hooks") did not disable the hook on Codex — it removed the
explicit declaration that was overriding the fallback, so the fallback
took over and found the Claude hooks/hooks.json.

Declare an empty inline hooks object ({}) in .codex-plugin/plugin.json.
It parses as an empty inline hook set and stops Codex reaching the
auto-discovery fallback. An absent field, an empty array ([]), and an
empty inline list all collapse back to the fallback, so the value must
be exactly {}.

Update the test to assert the manifest declares hooks: {} (and that
hooks/hooks.json exists, which is what makes the declaration necessary),
replacing the prior assertion that the field was absent — which passed
while the hook was still being auto-discovered.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-30 15:38:20 -07:00
4 changed files with 91 additions and 30 deletions

View File

@@ -90,7 +90,7 @@ every session, with no per-session opt-in by your human partner.** This is the
one non-negotiable capability. It can take any form:
- a **hook/event system** that runs a shell command at session start and reads
its stdout (Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot CLI), or
its stdout (Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Copilot CLI), or
- an **in-process plugin/extension** with a session-start or message lifecycle
callback that can mutate the message array (OpenCode, pi), or
- an **instructions-file** convention where the harness loads a context file that
@@ -227,20 +227,18 @@ you may **not** do is bridge a gap by editing the user's global config.
The harness has a hook system that runs a shell command at session start and
reads JSON from its stdout. The configured command runs `run-hook.cmd`, a
polyglot wrapper that just locates bash and dispatches the named script; the
script (`hooks/session-start`, or a harness-specific variant) is what reads
`using-superpowers/SKILL.md` and prints a JSON object whose **field name and
nesting differ per harness**.
script (`hooks/session-start`, or a harness-specific variant like
`hooks/session-start-codex`) is what reads `using-superpowers/SKILL.md` and
prints a JSON object whose **field name and nesting differ per harness**.
- Reference: `hooks/session-start`, `hooks/run-hook.cmd`, and the per-harness
hook config `hooks/hooks.json` (Claude Code) and `hooks/hooks-cursor.json`
- Reference: `hooks/session-start` (and `hooks/session-start-codex`),
`hooks/run-hook.cmd`, and the per-harness hook config `hooks/hooks.json`
(Claude Code), `hooks/hooks-codex.json` (Codex), `hooks/hooks-cursor.json`
(Cursor).
- Manifests: `.cursor-plugin/plugin.json` is the Shape A manifest example that
points the harness at `./skills/` and the right `hooks-*.json`. Claude Code's
- Manifests: `.codex-plugin/plugin.json`, `.cursor-plugin/plugin.json` point the
harness at `./skills/` and the right `hooks-*.json`. (Claude Code's
`.claude-plugin/plugin.json` sets neither field — it auto-discovers `skills/`
and `hooks/hooks.json` by convention. Do **not** copy Codex's
`.codex-plugin/plugin.json` for Shape A: it declares an empty `hooks` object
specifically to suppress Codex's `hooks/hooks.json` auto-discovery, because
Codex surfaces skills natively and runs no session-start hook.
and `hooks/hooks.json` by convention.)
> **A hook *system* is not a session-start *event*.** A harness can have a
> `hooks.json` mechanism — and even contain the literal string `SessionStart` in
@@ -289,7 +287,7 @@ part of the installed extension** — never substitute "edit the user's global
| If the harness… | Use shape | Copy from |
|---|---|---|
| runs a shell command at session start and reads its stdout | A (shell-hook) | Cursor (`hooks/session-start` + `hooks/hooks-cursor.json` + `.cursor-plugin/`) |
| runs a shell command at session start and reads its stdout | A (shell-hook) | Codex (`hooks/session-start-codex` + `hooks/hooks-codex.json` + `.codex-plugin/`) |
| is a JS/TS plugin host with session/message lifecycle callbacks | B (in-process) | OpenCode (`.opencode/`) — or pi (`.pi/`) if it has no native skill tool |
| ships an extension-declared context file it always loads | C (instructions-file) | Gemini (`gemini-extension.json` + `GEMINI.md` + `references/gemini-tools.md`) |
| has a plugin install command and a manifest `contextFileName` (or equivalent) the installer keeps | C via the plugin installer | Antigravity (`.antigravity-plugin/``agy plugin install` ships a generated context file; verify the installer preserves it — Part 6) |
@@ -311,7 +309,7 @@ patterns below are summaries; the code is the spec.
Create whatever the harness uses to recognize the plugin. Match the existing
ones in spirit:
- **Shape A:** a `*-plugin/plugin.json` (see `.cursor-plugin/plugin.json`) with
- **Shape A:** a `*-plugin/plugin.json` (see `.codex-plugin/plugin.json`) with
`name`, `version`, `description`, author/license/keywords, `"skills":
"./skills/"`, and `"hooks": "./hooks/hooks-<harness>.json"`. Plus the
`hooks-<harness>.json` itself, registering a session-start hook whose command
@@ -377,24 +375,25 @@ both double-injects). Find the
exact field, nesting, and event-matcher values your harness expects. Then
decide: add a fourth branch to `hooks/session-start`, or — if the harness needs
a different bootstrap message or env contract — add a dedicated
`hooks/session-start-<harness>` script. If you add a branch
`hooks/session-start-<harness>` script, the way Codex did. If you add a branch
and your harness *also* sets an env var an earlier branch keys on (some harnesses
set `CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT` too), order your branch before the one that would
otherwise shadow it. Match the harness's
own event-matcher strings (Claude Code uses `startup|clear|compact`, Cursor
`sessionStart`); wrong matchers mean the hook silently never fires.
own event-matcher strings (Claude Code uses `startup|clear|compact`, Codex
`startup|resume|clear`, Cursor `sessionStart`); wrong matchers mean the hook
silently never fires.
The **hook-config schema itself varies per harness** — don't assume the
Claude Code shape is universal. Compare `hooks/hooks.json` and
`hooks/hooks-cursor.json`: Cursor's uses
Claude/Codex shape is universal. Compare `hooks/hooks.json`,
`hooks/hooks-codex.json`, and `hooks/hooks-cursor.json`: Cursor's uses
`"version": 1`, a lowercase `sessionStart` key, a relative
`./hooks/run-hook.cmd` command, and omits the `matcher`/`type`/`async` fields
Claude Code uses. Match your `hooks-<harness>.json` to whichever existing file is
`./hooks/run-hook.cmd` command, and omits the `matcher`/`type`/`async` fields the
others use. Match your `hooks-<harness>.json` to whichever existing file is
closest, not to a single canonical template.
The hook **command string references a harness-provided plugin-root variable**,
and its name differs per harness: `hooks.json` uses `${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}`,
`hooks-cursor.json` uses a relative path. Use
`hooks-codex.json` uses `${PLUGIN_ROOT}`, Cursor uses a relative path. Use
whatever your harness exports. (The `session-start` script re-derives the root
itself via `dirname`, so the script body doesn't depend on this — but the
command in the manifest does.)
@@ -785,7 +784,7 @@ Use this as the live index; when in doubt, read the files, not this table.
| Harness | Entry point | Bootstrap mechanism | Tool mapping | Tests | Distribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Code | `.claude-plugin/plugin.json` + `hooks/hooks.json` | shell hook → `hooks/session-start` (`hookSpecificOutput.additionalContext`) | native `Skill` tool; `references/claude-code-tools.md` | `tests/hooks/` | marketplace |
| Codex | `.codex-plugin/plugin.json` (declares empty `hooks`) | native skill discovery (no session-start hook) | `references/codex-tools.md` | `tests/codex/`, `tests/codex-plugin-sync/` | fork sync (`scripts/sync-to-codex-plugin.sh`) |
| Codex | `.codex-plugin/plugin.json` + `hooks/hooks-codex.json` | shell hook → `hooks/session-start-codex` | `references/codex-tools.md` | `tests/codex-plugin-sync/`, `tests/hooks/` | fork sync (`scripts/sync-to-codex-plugin.sh`) |
| Cursor | `.cursor-plugin/plugin.json` + `hooks/hooks-cursor.json` | shell hook → `hooks/session-start` (`additional_context`) | `references/claude-code-tools.md` | `tests/hooks/` | hand-authored |
| Copilot CLI | (shares Claude Code hook path; `COPILOT_CLI` env) | shell hook → `hooks/session-start` (`additionalContext`) | `references/copilot-tools.md` | `tests/hooks/` | — |
| Gemini CLI | `gemini-extension.json` + `GEMINI.md` | instructions file `@`-includes bootstrap + mapping | `references/gemini-tools.md` | — | `gemini extensions install` |
@@ -800,10 +799,10 @@ Use this as the live index; when in doubt, read the files, not this table.
- **Wrong JSON field → silent failure or double injection.** Shape A only.
Confirm the exact field/nesting; Claude Code reads two fields without dedup.
- **Hook-config schema varies per harness.** Shape A. Cursor's `hooks-cursor.json`
looks nothing like the Claude Code one (`version`, lowercase `sessionStart`,
looks nothing like the Claude/Codex one (`version`, lowercase `sessionStart`,
relative command, no `matcher`/`type`/`async`). Match the closest existing file.
- **Plugin-root env var differs per harness.** Shape A. The hook command uses
`${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}` (Claude) or a relative path
`${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}` (Claude), `${PLUGIN_ROOT}` (Codex), or a relative path
(Cursor). Use what your harness exports; the script re-derives the root itself.
- **System-message injection.** Shape B injects a *user* message on purpose
(#750, #894). Don't "fix" it to a system message.

View File

@@ -140,7 +140,7 @@ Check that the script filename is **extensionless** in `hooks.json`. A command l
### Hook doesn't fire at all
Verify the `matcher` in `hooks.json` matches the event type your harness emits. Claude Code uses `startup|clear|compact`; Cursor uses `sessionStart`. Check `hooks-cursor.json` for the Cursor variant.
Verify the `matcher` in `hooks.json` matches the event type your harness emits. Claude Code uses `startup|clear|compact`; Codex uses `startup|resume|clear`. Check `hooks-codex.json` for the Codex variant.
## Related Issues

26
hooks/session-start-codex Executable file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
#!/usr/bin/env bash
# Codex SessionStart hook for superpowers plugin
set -euo pipefail
SCRIPT_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "$0")" && pwd)"
PLUGIN_ROOT="$(cd "${SCRIPT_DIR}/.." && pwd)"
using_superpowers_content=$(cat "${PLUGIN_ROOT}/skills/using-superpowers/SKILL.md" 2>&1 || echo "Error reading using-superpowers skill")
escape_for_json() {
local s="$1"
s="${s//\\/\\\\}"
s="${s//\"/\\\"}"
s="${s//$'\n'/\\n}"
s="${s//$'\r'/\\r}"
s="${s//$'\t'/\\t}"
printf '%s' "$s"
}
using_superpowers_escaped=$(escape_for_json "$using_superpowers_content")
session_context="<EXTREMELY_IMPORTANT>\nYou have superpowers.\n\n**Below is the full content of your 'superpowers:using-superpowers' skill - your introduction to using skills. For all other skills, follow the Codex skill-loading instructions in that skill:**\n\n${using_superpowers_escaped}\n</EXTREMELY_IMPORTANT>"
printf '{\n "hookSpecificOutput": {\n "hookEventName": "SessionStart",\n "additionalContext": "%s"\n }\n}\n' "$session_context" | cat
exit 0

View File

@@ -4,6 +4,7 @@ set -euo pipefail
SCRIPT_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "$0")" && pwd)"
REPO_ROOT="$(cd "$SCRIPT_DIR/../.." && pwd)"
HOOK_UNDER_TEST="$REPO_ROOT/hooks/session-start"
CODEX_HOOK_UNDER_TEST="$REPO_ROOT/hooks/session-start-codex"
WRAPPER_UNDER_TEST="$REPO_ROOT/hooks/run-hook.cmd"
FAILURES=0
@@ -153,15 +154,35 @@ assert_command_output \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
bash "$HOOK_UNDER_TEST"
wrapper_home="$(make_home run-hook-wrapper)"
codex_home="$(make_home codex-plugin-hooks)"
codex_data="$TEST_ROOT/codex-plugin-hooks/data"
mkdir -p "$codex_data"
assert_command_output \
"run-hook.cmd wrapper dispatches to the named session-start script" \
"Codex plugin hooks use dedicated script and emit nested SessionStart additionalContext" \
"nested" \
"" \
"" \
"$wrapper_home" \
"$codex_home" \
PLUGIN_DATA="$codex_data" \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_DATA="$codex_data" \
PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
bash "$WRAPPER_UNDER_TEST" session-start
bash "$CODEX_HOOK_UNDER_TEST"
codex_wrapper_home="$(make_home codex-wrapper)"
codex_wrapper_data="$TEST_ROOT/codex-wrapper/data"
mkdir -p "$codex_wrapper_data"
assert_command_output \
"Codex wrapper path dispatches to dedicated script" \
"nested" \
"" \
"" \
"$codex_wrapper_home" \
PLUGIN_DATA="$codex_wrapper_data" \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_DATA="$codex_wrapper_data" \
PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
bash "$WRAPPER_UNDER_TEST" session-start-codex
cursor_home="$(make_home cursor)"
assert_command_output \
@@ -196,6 +217,21 @@ assert_command_output \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
bash "$HOOK_UNDER_TEST"
codex_legacy_home="$(make_home codex-legacy-warning-removed)"
codex_legacy_data="$TEST_ROOT/codex-legacy-warning-removed/data"
mkdir -p "$codex_legacy_home/.config/superpowers/skills" "$codex_legacy_data"
assert_command_output \
"Codex SessionStart omits obsolete legacy custom-skill warning" \
"nested" \
"" \
"Superpowers now uses"$'\037'"~/.config/superpowers/skills"$'\037'"~/.claude/skills"$'\037'"legacy" \
"$codex_legacy_home" \
PLUGIN_DATA="$codex_legacy_data" \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_DATA="$codex_legacy_data" \
PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT="$REPO_ROOT" \
bash "$CODEX_HOOK_UNDER_TEST"
if [[ "$FAILURES" -gt 0 ]]; then
echo "STATUS: FAILED ($FAILURES failure(s))"
exit 1